Joshua Tiernan
Level 13

Joshua Tiernan

2Thoughts
0Following
8Followers

Founder at No Code Founders

The Myth of the Big Idea

I once built a wedding directory business. I secured funding for it. I spent months building it. And it failed. Not because I wasn't capable, not because I didn't work hard, but because I never properly asked whether anyone actually wanted it before I committed everything to it. That's a difficult thing to admit. But it's the most useful thing I can tell you about startups. Here's what happened inside my head during that period. I got the idea, and something lit up. I started seeing the potential everywhere. I could picture the couples using it, the vendors paying for listings, the revenue model. It all made sense. And then, almost without noticing, I stopped asking is this real? and started asking how do I build this? That shift is where most startups begin to die. The funding made it worse, not better. Having someone else believe in the idea felt like validation. It wasn't. It was one person's opinion, expressed with money. That's a very different thing from the market telling you it wants what you're building. But at the time, it felt like proof. So I built. Several months later, I had a product and no customers. Not because the execution was poor. Because the question of whether anyone genuinely wanted this, at this price, in this format, from this brand, had never been properly answered. I had assumed the answer was yes. I had built on that assumption. And the assumption was wrong. This is wishful thinking. Not stupidity. Not laziness. The quiet, optimistic belief that because you can see the value in something, the market probably can too. The brutal truth is that belief isn't evidence. Excitement isn't validation. And the more capable you are as a founder, the more dangerous this gets. A capable person can build something no one asked for extremely well. They can launch it with genuine polish, write compelling copy, price it properly. And it still fails. Because the question of whether anyone wanted it was never honestly answered. I've watched this play out across the No Code Founders community for years. Smart people, real skills, ideas that made complete sense inside their own heads. But somewhere between the idea and the launch, they skipped the most important step: genuinely trying to find out what was wrong with it. Not "here's my idea, what do you think?" That question almost always gets you encouragement, because people are kind. The real question is harder. What's the most likely reason this fails? What would have to be true for this to work, and is it actually true? Who is the person that would pay for this, and have you talked to them honestly, without pitching them first? Most founders never ask those questions with any rigour. Because asking them properly means entertaining the possibility that the idea isn't as good as you feel it is. So instead you move forward on hope and call it confidence. The antidote isn't pessimism. It's structured honesty. Before you build anything, try to kill the idea yourself. Write down the three most likely reasons it fails. Talk to potential customers without revealing what you're building. Listen to what they actually complain about. Let the idea be interrogated before you've invested months of your life into it. The wedding directory taught me something I've carried into every startup since. Real belief can survive scrutiny. Wishful thinking can't. And the fastest way to find out which one you have is to actively try to prove yourself wrong, before the market does it for you.

Wishful Thinking Will Kill Your Startup

Discover more content and chat further with Joshua Tiernan, or on

By using this service, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.